I've never had a problem with Ryan's reviews and this is his opinion and he's entitled to it. The game isn't even out yet, so naturally I can't say anything about the game play. But I find it somewhat troubling that he would give the game a horrible rating of 5.2 or whatever it was. I've never seen such a low rating game giving by IGN. They are notorious these days for giving "less than stellar" games a good grade. Most other sites that have the game for review are averaging around 8 out of 10, which is what I was expecting. Although Gamespot gave it a 6. I'm gonna wait to see what the consensus is of paying costumers, not those that get the game for free, before I make up my mind on getting the game or not.